Measure: Fire Marshal Fee Ordinance (Appeal of Law Department Ruling)

Passed on 2023-04-17

Aamina Ahmad, Assistant Town Attorney ruled that the Moss amendment to Item No. 3 was not in legal order. Thomas J. Byrne, Member of District 6, appealed the legal opinion of the Law Department pursuant to RTM Rule III. I.3.b.1.

Related measures:

At a Glance

Party Breakdown

  • Democrats were most likely to vote: Yes
  • Republicans were split between: Yes and No
  • Unaffiliateds were most likely to vote: Yes

Vote Breakdown

Overall Outcome

Outcome by District

Votes by District

Votes Cast

RTM

Name District Vote Modality
Robert M. Chaney District 11 Yes In Person
Romulo E. Samaniego District 4 Yes In Person
Lihong Zhang District 1 Yes Remote
Michael J. Kiselak District 3 Yes In Person
Jonathan R. Shankman District 9 Yes Remote
Henry Scott Walter District 2 Yes In Person
Erika Walsh District 2 Absent Absent
William W. Galvin III District 7 Absent Absent
Gregory J. Zorthian District 11 Yes In Person
Edward T. Broadhurst III District 5 Absent Absent
Scott E. Kalb District 7 Yes In Person
Diego Sanchez District 4 Yes In Person
Sheryl B. Sorbaro District 10 Absent Absent
Valerie Stauffer District 7 No In Person
Peter E. Berg District 8 Yes Remote
Jane S. Sulich District 12 Yes Remote
Daniel E. P. Quigley District 1 No In Person
Maria Bocchino District 4 Yes In Person
Richard J. Margenot District 8 Absent Absent
Mareta C. Hamre District 10 Yes In Person
Cathryn Fineman "Cathy" Steel District 11 Yes In Person
Marilyn Ross Cahn District 6 Did Not Vote Remote
John M. Merrill District 6 Yes In Person
Susan Fahey District 11 Yes In Person
Debbie L. Appelbaum District 7 No In Person
David P. Snyder District 6 Yes In Person
Mary Tobin District 6 Yes In Person
James Waters District 12 Yes In Person
Kara L. Philbin District 10 No In Person
David E. Oliver District 11 Absent Absent
Donald R. Conway District 2 Yes In Person
Brigitte A. Lee District 1 No In Person
Thomas J. Byrne District 6 Yes In Person
Jillian C. Aufderheide District 1 Yes Remote
Felice "Felix" Rovelli District 5 Yes Remote
Carl G. R. Carlson Jr. District 1 Yes Remote
Abbe F. Large District 9 No Remote
Marla M. Weston District 1 Yes In Person
Karsten A. Vagner District 3 Yes In Person
Steven B. Katz District 10 Absent Absent
Steven P. Rubin District 3 Yes In Person
Daniel C. Schreck District 10 No In Person
Elizabeth Porcher "Shaye" Hester District 9 Yes Remote
Thomas Agresta District 12 Yes In Person
Allison W. Rogers District 5 Yes In Person
Martin Cristian Blanco District 3 Absent Absent
Claudia A. Carthaus District 9 Yes Remote
Janet McMahon District 8 Yes In Person
Sally E. Bednar District 6 Yes In Person
Edward D. Dadakis District 1 Yes Remote
Alexis Voulgaris District 6 Did Not Vote In Person
Paul A. Olmsted District 5 No In Person
Jane C. Weisbecker District 9 Yes Remote
Eric P. Beiley District 5 Yes Remote
Hilary A. Gunn District 7 Yes In Person
Anne N. Jones "Dawson" District 9 Absent Absent
Louisa H. Stone District 10 Yes In Person
Allison C. "Icy" Frantz District 5 Yes In Person
Nancy F. Dearing District 6 Yes In Person
Tracy H. Freedman District 11 Absent Absent
Brad Radulovacki District 11 Yes In Person
Barbara E. O'Neill District 6 Yes In Person
Tracy D. Parsons "Grossman" District 6 Absent Absent
Henry A. Orphys District 7 No In Person
Joanne I. Steinhart District 9 Yes Remote
Alice B. Duff District 7 No In Person
Peter G. Van Duyne District 5 No In Person
Kathleen M. Myer District 8 Yes In Person
Christine L. Edwards District 8 Yes In Person
Robert T. May District 12 Yes In Person
Victoria Martin Young District 6 Yes In Person
Jesus Jhoni Puerta Lopez District 3 Did Not Vote In Person
Lucy von Brachel District 4 Yes In Person
Glen A. Canner District 12 Yes In Person
Donna F. Gaudioso-Zeale District 9 Yes In Person
Coline Jenkins District 6 Yes In Person
Catherine L. Whitaker District 5 Yes Remote
Frederick R. Feldman District 1 Yes In Person
Averardo "Aldo" Pascarella District 2 Did Not Vote In Person
Richard S. Montier District 12 Yes Remote
Ellen Murdock District 12 Yes In Person
Cory G. Williams District 8 Did Not Vote Remote
Rosemarie Macaluso District 4 No In Person
Ronald G. Strackbein District 11 Yes In Person
Mark R. Kordick District 9 Yes Remote
Andrew Oliver II District 8 No Remote
Carol C. Ducret District 6 No In Person
Vincent C. Pastore District 8 No In Person
Thomas J. Cahill District 7 No In Person
Ramya T. Hopley District 10 No Remote
Victoria C. Bostock District 11 Yes In Person
Elizabeth J. "Liz" Eckert District 4 Yes Remote
Alanna M. Hynes District 1 Absent Absent
Craig W. Amundson District 12 Yes In Person
Joyce P. "Jay" Teevan District 2 Yes In Person
Elizabeth "Wynn" McDaniel District 7 No In Person
M. Irene Dietrich District 8 Yes In Person
Donald R. Vitti District 4 Yes In Person
Elizabeth Mills "Sanders" District 1 Yes In Person
Frederick Lee Jr District 1 No In Person
Geralyn Beth O. Rubenstein District 9 Yes In Person
Ferdinando G. Schiro District 9 Yes Remote
Javier A. Aleman District 4 Absent Absent
Jocelyn Y. Riddle District 12 Yes In Person
Marina Rosin District 7 Yes Remote
Nancy B. Burke District 2 No In Person
Cheryl A. Moss District 8 Yes In Person
Alan A. Small District 10 Yes Remote
Nancy M. Better District 11 Yes In Person
Mary Connolly Flynn District 12 Yes In Person
Abigail R. McCarthy District 12 Absent Absent
Mary Ellen D. Markowitz District 2 Yes In Person
Joseph H. Benoit Jr. District 5 Yes In Person
Lucy B. Krasnor District 5 Yes In Person
Adam M. Brodsky District 11 Yes Remote
Lindy M. Lilien District 5 Yes Remote
Andrew R. Melillo District 3 Did Not Vote In Person
Chalon W. Lefebvre District 12 Abstain Remote
Seth W. Bacon District 4 No Remote
Ed J. Lopez District 3 Yes Remote
Daniel Izzo District 6 Yes Remote
Thomas M. Devaney District 11 No In Person
Jan Rogers Kniffen District 11 Yes Remote
Mary G. "Nanette" Burrows District 7 No In Person
Lynn B. Garelick District 1 Yes In Person
Caryn S. Rosenbaum District 8 Absent Absent
David de Milhau District 12 Yes In Person
Eileen J. Toretta District 2 Yes In Person
Robert J. McKnight Jr. District 4 Yes In Person
Anthony James Moor District 7 Yes In Person
John S. Hopley District 10 No Remote
Christopher "Skip" Parker Jr. District 5 Absent Absent
Rosalind Nicastro District 3 No In Person
Francis J. "Kip" Burgweger Jr District 8 Yes In Person
Andrew S. Winston District 12 Absent Absent
Alison F. Soler District 8 Absent Absent
Philip A. Dodson District 8 No In Person
Dana G. Neuman District 11 Yes Remote
J. Robert Tuthill District 4 Absent Absent
Alison W. Ghiorse District 1 Absent Absent
Kathleen S. "Kathy" Smith District 6 Yes Remote
Thomas M. West District 11 Yes In Person
Jill M. Capalbo District 8 Absent Absent
Aaron J. Leonard District 12 Yes In Person
Frederick R. Lorthioir District 12 Absent Absent
Margaret G. Heppelmann District 11 Yes Remote
Alexander J. Popp District 4 No In Person
Stephen R. Meskers District 6 Yes In Person
Bonnie Zeh District 4 Absent Absent
William B. Lewis Jr. District 1 Yes Remote
Elizabeth C. Mac Gillivray District 7 No Remote
Donato "Dan" Sinisi District 9 No In Person
Myra H. Klockenbrink District 8 Yes In Person
Ronald F. Carosella District 4 No In Person
Allyson T. Cowin District 10 No Remote
Hector E. Arzeno District 8 Yes In Person
Mary A. Keller District 12 No In Person
James J. O'Brien District 1 Yes Remote
Pragati Soni District 2 Yes In Person
Ellen M. Brennan-Galvin District 7 Absent Absent
Jaysen Lee Medhurst District 1 Yes In Person
Katherine N. LoBalbo District 2 Yes In Person
Tara S. Restieri District 7 Yes In Person
Paul E. Kramer District 5 Yes Remote
Betsey S. Frumin District 9 Yes Remote
Lauren B. O'Keefe District 9 Yes In Person
Dana Gordon District 8 Did Not Vote Remote
Paula Legere-Mickley District 12 Absent Absent
Randy Caravella District 8 No Remote
Wilma Nacinovich District 2 No In Person
Joan B. Thakor District 5 Absent Absent
Andrew B. Taylor District 5 No In Person
Joshua H. Brown District 4 Yes In Person
Elizabeth "Betsy" J. Galindo District 7 Did Not Vote In Person
Samuelle "Sammie" Terese Lazar Jacobs District 8 Yes Remote
Christina P. Volkwein District 2 No In Person
Jane S. Sprung District 10 No In Person
Francia Alvarez District 12 Yes In Person
Karen B. Giannuzzi District 11 Yes In Person
Samarpana Tamm District 4 Yes In Person
Sylvester J. Pecora Sr. District 3 Yes In Person
Robert W. Carter District 6 Yes In Person
Luke Szymczak District 7 No Remote
Judith G. Goss District 1 Yes In Person
P. Jude Collins District 10 Yes In Person
Matt DesChamps District 6 Yes In Person
Dean C. Goss District 1 Yes In Person
Nerlyn G. Pierson District 11 Yes Remote
Kimberly D. Salib District 11 No In Person
Katharine Ashworth District 1 Absent Absent
Julia H. Lane District 1 Yes In Person
Brian J. Malin District 9 No Remote
Patricia "Patti" DeFelice District 9 Yes In Person
Sunghi P. Frauen District 7 No Remote
W. Brooks Harris District 10 No In Person
Richard J. Neuman District 11 No In Person
Martha Ozizmir Shoemaker District 5 Yes In Person
Carol A. Zarrilli District 9 Absent Absent
Laura P. Gladstone District 2 Did Not Vote In Person
Michael P. Brescia District 9 No In Person
Debra Ciampi Kolman District 10 No Remote
Ashley M. B. Smith District 5 Yes In Person
Adam L. Leader District 11 Yes In Person
Duncan G. Burke District 2 No In Person
Gerald L. Anderson District 10 Yes In Person
Sandra K. Harris District 10 No Remote
Laura Darrin District 11 No Remote
Barbara T. Darula District 9 Yes Remote
Jonathan M. Perloe District 8 Absent Absent
Anne Driscoll District 10 No Remote
Barbara Galton Hindman District 12 Yes In Person
Lucia D. Jansen District 7 No In Person
John M. McShea District 6 Yes In Person
Adele Caroll District 8 No Remote
Hannah P. Doherty District 8 Absent Absent
Lisa Becker Edmundson District 8 No In Person
Charles H. Parkhurst District 5 Yes In Person
Michael Spilo District 11 No In Person
David J. Lancaster District 12 Yes In Person
Kimberly Morgan Blank District 7 Did Not Vote Remote
Radhika A. Patel District 10 Absent Absent
Mary M. "Molly" Saleeby District 8 Yes In Person
Andrea J. Casson District 4 Yes In Person
Peter J. Quigley District 3 Abstain In Person
Katherine V. Hynes District 10 Yes In Person
Jonathan A. Kantor District 12 No In Person
Carl Griffasi District 9 Absent Absent
Brian J. Maher District 6 Yes Remote
Hilary Haroche District 10 No In Person