Measure: Motion - Limit Debate
Passed on 2023-01-17
Edward T. Broadhurst, III, Member of District 5, made a motion to limit debate to two (2) minutes per speaker per item per motion, except that the proponent and principal opponent (the latter to be determined by the Moderator) shall be entitled to speak for five (5) minutes each for the remainder of the meeting, which was duly moved and seconded.
At a Glance
Party Breakdown
- Democrats were most likely to vote: Yes
- Republicans were most likely to vote: Yes
- Unaffiliateds were most likely to vote: Yes
Vote Breakdown
Overall Outcome
Outcome by District
Votes by District
Votes Cast
RTM
| Name | District | Vote | Modality |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joanne I. Steinhart | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Peter E. Berg | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Mary Ellen D. Markowitz | District 2 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Carl G. R. Carlson Jr. | District 1 | No | Remote |
| Barbara E. O'Neill | District 6 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Mary M. "Molly" Saleeby | District 8 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Steven P. Rubin | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Paul A. Olmsted | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Jan Rogers Kniffen | District 11 | Yes | Remote |
| Randy Caravella | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Christine L. Edwards | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Cory G. Williams | District 8 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Karsten A. Vagner | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Steven B. Katz | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Aaron J. Leonard | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| Robert W. Carter | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Christina P. Volkwein | District 2 | No | In Person |
| Adam A. Rothman | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Kimberly D. Salib | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Alison F. Soler | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Michael J. Kiselak | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Peter J. Quigley | District 3 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Richard J. Margenot | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Lihong Zhang | District 1 | Yes | Remote |
| Abbe F. Large | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Victoria C. Bostock | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Allison C. "Icy" Frantz | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Valerie Stauffer | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Hector E. Arzeno | District 8 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Kara L. Philbin | District 10 | No | In Person |
| Rosemarie Macaluso | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Alison W. Ghiorse | District 1 | Yes | Remote |
| Susan Fahey | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| David J. Lancaster | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Lindy M. Lilien | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth "Betsy" J. Galindo | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| J. Robert Tuthill | District 4 | Absent | Absent |
| Robert J. McKnight Jr. | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Allison W. Rogers | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth Porcher "Shaye" Hester | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Nancy M. Better | District 11 | Abstain | Remote |
| Richard S. Montier | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| Anthony James Moor | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Averardo "Aldo" Pascarella | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Thomas J. Cahill | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Brian J. Malin | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Nancy B. Burke | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Gerald L. Anderson | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Sylvester J. Pecora Sr. | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Sandra K. Harris | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Thomas Agresta | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Samuelle "Sammie" Terese Lazar Jacobs | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Jonathan A. Kantor | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Victoria Martin Young | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Alan A. Small | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Edward T. Broadhurst III | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth "Wynn" McDaniel | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Luke Szymczak | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Dana Gordon | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Barbara T. Darula | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Katherine V. Hynes | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Francia Alvarez | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| John S. Hopley | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Adam L. Leader | District 11 | No | In Person |
| Mary A. Keller | District 12 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Cheryl A. Moss | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Craig W. Amundson | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| M. Irene Dietrich | District 8 | No | In Person |
| Jesus Jhoni Puerta Lopez | District 3 | Absent | Absent |
| Chalon W. Lefebvre | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| Frederick Lee Jr | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Sally E. Bednar | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Jonathan M. Perloe | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Michael Spilo | District 11 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Robert T. May | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Frederick R. Feldman | District 1 | Absent | Absent |
| Anne Driscoll | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Julia H. Lane | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| David de Milhau | District 12 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Bonnie Zeh | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Claudia A. Carthaus | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth Mills "Sanders" | District 1 | No | In Person |
| Matt DesChamps | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| W. Brooks Harris | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Samarpana Tamm | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| John M. Merrill | District 6 | Yes | Remote |
| Alexander J. Popp | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| P. Jude Collins | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| William W. Galvin III | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Andrew Oliver II | District 8 | No | In Person |
| Marla M. Weston | District 1 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Mary G. "Nanette" Burrows | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| David E. Oliver | District 11 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Hannah P. Doherty | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Louisa H. Stone | District 10 | No | In Person |
| Glen A. Canner | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Mary Connolly Flynn | District 12 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Ramya T. Hopley | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Peter G. Van Duyne | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Jaysen Lee Medhurst | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Gregory J. Zorthian | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Carol A. Zarrilli | District 9 | No | In Person |
| Andrew B. Taylor | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Katharine Ashworth | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Charles H. Parkhurst | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Ashley M. B. Smith | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Thomas M. West | District 11 | Yes | Remote |
| Seth W. Bacon | District 4 | No | In Person |
| John M. McShea | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Alanna M. Hynes | District 1 | Absent | Absent |
| Janet McMahon | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Adam M. Brodsky | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Lisa Becker Edmundson | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Stephen R. Meskers | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Erika Walsh | District 2 | Yes | Remote |
| Martin Cristian Blanco | District 3 | Yes | In Person |
| Dana G. Neuman | District 11 | Yes | Remote |
| Henry Scott Walter | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Mary Tobin | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Debbie L. Appelbaum | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Caryn S. Rosenbaum | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Christopher "Skip" Parker Jr. | District 5 | Absent | Absent |
| Ellen M. Brennan-Galvin | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Lucy von Brachel | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Patricia "Patti" DeFelice | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Debra Ciampi Kolman | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Sheryl B. Sorbaro | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Paula Legere-Mickley | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| Katherine N. LoBalbo | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Paul E. Kramer | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Joshua H. Brown | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Martha Ozizmir Shoemaker | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Ralph E. Penny | District 11 | Absent | Absent |
| Geralyn Beth O. Rubenstein | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Nancy F. Dearing | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Laura P. Gladstone | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Alexis Voulgaris | District 6 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Cathryn Fineman "Cathy" Steel | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Anne N. Jones "Dawson" | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Kathleen S. "Kathy" Smith | District 6 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Judith G. Goss | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Joseph H. Benoit Jr. | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Henry A. Orphys | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Philip A. Dodson | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Donna F. Gaudioso-Zeale | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Duncan G. Burke | District 2 | Yes | Remote |
| Nerlyn G. Pierson | District 11 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Barbara Galton Hindman | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Jill M. Capalbo | District 8 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Carl Griffasi | District 9 | Absent | Absent |
| Frederick R. Lorthioir | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Carol C. Ducret | District 6 | Yes | Remote |
| David P. Snyder | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Dean C. Goss | District 1 | No | In Person |
| Tracy D. Parsons "Grossman" | District 6 | Yes | Remote |
| Michael P. Brescia | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Daniel E. P. Quigley | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Wilma Nacinovich | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Ronald F. Carosella | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| James Waters | District 12 | Yes | Remote |
| Joyce P. "Jay" Teevan | District 2 | Yes | Remote |
| Radhika A. Patel | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Ed J. Lopez | District 3 | No | In Person |
| Jonathan R. Shankman | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Diego Sanchez | District 4 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Rosalind Nicastro | District 3 | Yes | Remote |
| Marilyn Ross Cahn | District 6 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Donald R. Conway | District 2 | Absent | Absent |
| Laura Darrin | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Kathleen M. Myer | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Lucia D. Jansen | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth C. Mac Gillivray | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Sunghi P. Frauen | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Daniel Izzo | District 6 | Yes | Remote |
| Thomas J. Byrne | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Edward D. Dadakis | District 1 | Yes | Remote |
| Hilary A. Gunn | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Andrea J. Casson | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Eileen J. Toretta | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Donald R. Vitti | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Alice B. Duff | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Jane S. Sulich | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Mareta C. Hamre | District 10 | Abstain | Remote |
| Jane S. Sprung | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Kimberly Morgan Blank | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Allyson T. Cowin | District 10 | Yes | Remote |
| Ellen Murdock | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| James J. O'Brien | District 1 | Yes | Remote |
| Lucy B. Krasnor | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Catherine L. Whitaker | District 5 | Yes | In Person |
| Margaret G. Heppelmann | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Tracy H. Freedman | District 11 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Scott E. Kalb | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Eric P. Beiley | District 5 | Yes | Remote |
| Richard J. Neuman | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Jane C. Weisbecker | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Daniel C. Schreck | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Coline Jenkins | District 6 | Yes | In Person |
| Lynn B. Garelick | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Thomas M. Devaney | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Mark R. Kordick | District 9 | No | Remote |
| Brad Radulovacki | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Myra H. Klockenbrink | District 8 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Betsey S. Frumin | District 9 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| William B. Lewis Jr. | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Donato "Dan" Sinisi | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Karen B. Giannuzzi | District 11 | Yes | In Person |
| Andrew R. Melillo | District 3 | No | In Person |
| Adele Caroll | District 8 | Yes | Remote |
| Felice "Felix" Rovelli | District 5 | Did Not Vote | Remote |
| Jocelyn Y. Riddle | District 12 | Did Not Vote | In Person |
| Brigitte A. Lee | District 1 | Yes | In Person |
| Javier A. Aleman | District 4 | Yes | Remote |
| Pragati Soni | District 2 | Yes | In Person |
| Hilary Haroche | District 10 | Yes | In Person |
| Francis J. "Kip" Burgweger Jr | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Andrew S. Winston | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Tara S. Restieri | District 7 | Yes | Remote |
| Lauren B. O'Keefe | District 9 | Yes | In Person |
| Vincent C. Pastore | District 8 | Yes | In Person |
| Jillian C. Aufderheide | District 1 | Yes | Remote |
| Marina Rosin | District 7 | Yes | In Person |
| Romulo E. Samaniego | District 4 | Yes | In Person |
| Abigail R. McCarthy | District 12 | Yes | In Person |
| Elizabeth J. "Liz" Eckert | District 4 | Yes | Remote |
| Brian J. Maher | District 6 | Yes | Remote |
| Maria Madeleine Popp | District 4 | No | In Person |
| Joan B. Thakor | District 5 | Yes | Remote |
| Ferdinando G. Schiro | District 9 | Yes | Remote |
| Ronald G. Strackbein | District 11 | Yes | In Person |